Just 3 ingredients Sweetened Condensed Milk Cookies

Sharing is caring!

Can you resist if I say you can make a delicious cookie using just 3 ingredients and in under 25 mins?? This Sweetened Condensed Milk Cookies is just that recipe.

What is Sweetened Condensed Milk Cookies?

Sweetened Condensed Milk Cookies is basically a cross between shortbread cookies and thumbprint cookies but in a simplified version. They have the delightful crumbly texture of shortbread that you can use as the base to jazz up with any filling of choice like a thumbprint cookie.

Why you must try this recipe?

1. Ease of the recipe - With just 3 ingredients and hardly any time needed, I bet you cannot go wrong with this recipe.
2. Basic recipe - Basic easy to follow with simple 4 steps instructions, this is the perfect recipe to try with kids or even as a beginner baker.
3. Variations - Well, this being the basic version you can jazz it up with endless variations to customise. Find a few suggestions in the post.
4. Easy to scale - This recipe can easily be doubled or halved.
5. Sells like hot cake - A very delicious cookie recipe that you can literally pack and sell. Easy to package, transport and would be a perfect addition to your cookie box for this festive season.
6. Use your leftovers - Wondering what to do with a can of condensed milk or have some leftover condensed milk in your fridge? This is the perfect milkmaid cookies recipe to use it up.

Ingredients Needed:

1. Plain Flour: that is APF works best for this recipe
2. Butter: needs to be chilled and cubed
3. Sweetened Condensed milk: Don't confuse this with evaporated milk. You would need condensed milk and not evaporated milk.

Step by Step instructions:

Step 1: Prepare the Dough

Combine together the flour and butter in a mixing bowl. Using your fingers rub the butter into the flour to create a wet sand like texture (image 1-2).

This technique of rubbing the fat into the flour is known as reverse creaming and it helps in making a tender cookie recipe by inhibiting the development of gluten.

You can check this Fresh Fruit Tart recipe if you would like to learn more about the science behind this reverse creaming technique more. (The post has a detailed explanation with infographics)

Once the flour and butter is rubbed well, add in the sweetened condensed milk to form into a cookie dough (image 2-3). Condensed milk acts as both the sweetening and the binding agent in this recipe.

If you find the dough to be sticky you can add a tbsp or two of flour and get it into a dough.

Step 2: Shaping

Using a tbsp as a measurement, take out the portion of the dough and roll it into a ball.

Then press the dough using the back of your spoon or your forefinger to make an impression (images 4-6).

There are two ways of filling the cookie now:

First Way:

In the first way, add 1/2 tsp of condensed milk in the impression created before baking. Then bake in the preheated oven (images 7-8).

Second Way:

In this method, you add the condensed milk once the cookies are baked.

So once out of the oven and still warm, you press the cookie again with the back of your tsp to create the well and the fill the cavity with the condensed milk (images 9-10).

Step 3 - Baking

No matter which way you choose to fill the cookie, bake them in a preheated oven of 180°C for 8-10 mins until the base of the cookie is golden brown and the top remains pale in colour.

Allow it to cool and crisp up.

Enjoy the delicious cookie.

Texture of Condensed Milk Biscuits

Depending upon which way you choose to fill the cookie, you would get a variation in the texture.

First Way:

When the cookies are baked with the filling, the sweetened condensed milk caramalizes a bit more, boils over and sets completely.

So when you bite into it or break the cookie into two using your fingers the condensed milk won't ooze out.

Making it perfect to be packaged and be shared eventually.

Second Way:

In this method, since the condensed milk is added after the cookie is baked it remains flowy in consistency, so when you bite into it the filling oozes out.

This type of sweetened condensed milk cookies is perfect for those who absolutely love eating the condensed milk on its own. I absolutely love this one.

Storage (Make-Ahead) Instructions

Store these cookies in an air-tight container at room temperature for up to 7 days.

Like any other cookie dough, this sweetened condensed milk cookie dough also freezes well.

How to freeze the cookie dough?

Once the dough is formed, shape it to a log, cling wrap and store in the freezer for up to 3 months.

When ready to bake, take it out from freezer, cut to form roundels; the process is similar to Tutti Fruiti cookies.

Please note in this case you cannot fill the cookies like a thumbprint cookies.

Instead you can treat them like the Jim Jam biscuits. Emma's goodies video explains it clearly.

Baker's Tips:

1. The most important thing to take care is that you are using Condensed Milk by Nestle or MilkMaid and not evaporated milk for this recipe.
2. If the dough feels sticky, add an additional tbsp of flour to bind them together.
3. Use a tbsp or tsp measurement to divide the dough into roundels. That way all your cookies will be evenly shaped.
4. While shaping the cookies might tend to dry out leading to formation of cracks. So work quickly while shaping and giving the impression on top.
5. If you feel that the base of the cookie gets too brown quickly, then follow the double pan technique while baking. This technique works well for all types of cookies.

Variations:

Like I said, this version of Sweetened Condensed Milk Cookies is a very basic version. You can alter the filling choice in so many ways.

Here are few examples for you:

1. Condensed Milk Chocolate Chip Cookies: You can add chocolate chips to the cookie dough and then make a ball and bake instead of the filling method.
2. Condensed Milk Peanut Butter Cookies: Fill the cookies with peanut butter instead of condensed milk. Actually any nut butter would work in place of peanut butter. So you can choose to fill almond butter, cashew butter or whatever you like the most.
3. Oreos: Crush the oreos and mix it with the dough. Divide into roundels and bake to form condensed milk oreo cookies.
4. Milo: Mix around 20 gms of Milo or any drink powder - Boost or even cocoa powder will work for chocolate version.
5. Caramel cookies: Just use homemade caramel sauce or butterscotch sauce for the filling in place of condensed milk.
6. Glazed condensed milk cookies: So instead of giving an impression on top, bake the cookies like a sugar cookie and then dip them in a simple sugar glaze and coat with sprinkles on top.

FAQ's:

Related Recipes:

1. Tutti Fruti Cookies
2. Fresh Fruit Tart
3. Nankhatai Biscuits

Wish to Join US for the love of BAKING? Subscribe to our newsletter and Youtube channel. Follow along on Facebook, Instagram, and Pinterest for all the latest updates! Grab your copy of Cake Pricing Guide from here.