Troubleshooting Common Sourdough Problems:
Problem 1: There is a brown or grey line in my starter
This line is called as HOOCH and is very common. Nothing to worry.
It indicates that the starter is hungry and needs to fed.
Simply mix the hooch in and feed your starter and it should be fine.
I personally experience this.. Check How to Make your Starter section for more details.
Problem 2: There is a pink streak on my starter's surface:
Red alert guy!!! A pink or a yellow streak indicates contamination.
If you see this at any stage simply discard everything and start over.
Problem 3: There are very little or no bubbles and my starter is not rising
Be Patient.
On Day 3 to Day 5 you might not observe any changes in your starter, neither will there be any activity or much bubbles.
Just continue.
Unless you have added hot water there is no chance that you have killed the yeast altogether.
So just keep going and keep feeding and you will observe the rising at some point. It may even take up to 10 days to see any activity.
Another thing you can do is change the quality of your flour and see.. Use premium quality flour or rye flour and test.
Or create a warm environment and test.
Problem 4: My Starter smells unpleasant
That is how it will be in the initial few days. So don't worry just continue.
Problem 5: My starter has collected water on top
Sometimes you might observe that the starter get a watery surface on top and a dough like consistency at the base.
This is not hooch specially if you are feeding it twice then there won't be any hooch development.
This actually indicates that you need to add more flour to balance the act out.
You might also observe the other way around that the starter is doughy and thick paste-like especially if you are using whole wheat flour.
In that case you need to add little water to adjust the consistency.
However in either cases, I did not adjust the flour or water proportions I simply stirred the starter and proceeded with the recipe.
Few Basic Tips:
- Use organic unbleached flour.
- Avoid chlorinated water. Try to use filtered warm water.
- Please weigh your ingredients.
- Make sure you’re storing your starter in a warm environment that encourages the fermentation process.
- Patience is the key. Keep feeding regularly and you will observe that your Yeast would surprise you when you are expecting it the least.
Susie says
Hi Sushma
I have tried a number of recipes and I am loving yours. Thank you so much. My question is when you feed your refrigerated starter once a week do you always use the whole wheat flour?
Thanks Susie
sushma iyer says
Hi Susie.. No you can use any type of flour - whole wheat or APF. I feed mine with APF
Shriram Parameswaran says
Very nicely structured and narrated post for a beginner like me in the sourdough journey.
Has anyone tried making the Sourdough starter with Aashirvaad Select (100% MP Sharbati wheat) flour?
sushma iyer says
Hi Shriram..
Thank you so much.. that was the whole point for this post.. For anyone to start their sourdough journey.. And yes I myself have made with Aashirvaad Atta.. The starter will be thick and paste like but as day passes it would become normal..
Regards
Sushma
Shriram Parameswaran says
Namaskarams
We are just going to commence our sourdough baking journey verybsoon, I hope.
Sourdough starter is getting ready and is eight days in the making. Eagerly waiting.
Chlorine in water and Iodine in Salt could kill the living organisms in the levain / starter, is what I hear and that makes sense.
So while we can use filtered and stored water (after chlorine has escaped) to get chlorine free water, which salt is recommended for sourdough baking.
Is the himalayan pink salt powder ok ?
And any idea which cast iron Dutch Oven is popular in India? Or is there any alternative to a D.O.?
We intend to start off with baking tins first for loaves and then graduate to a D.O. for Boules and Batards etc.,.
sushma iyer says
Hello Shriram..
Namaskaram..
So happy to learn your progress.. And your research on Sourdough is amazing. You are on the right track. Himalayan Pink Salt is absolutely fine. Works great.
Coming to D.O. You can check the LeCreuset India they have amazing collection. If you use Instagram you can check their page on Insta or do a quick Google Search too.
But if the shops are open I would say nothing like namma ooru iron pans so you can use iron skillet for both base and top. So not only for Boules you can use it in everyday cooking for making stir fry or dosas. I am talking about something like this in this picture that I found on google for you https://bit.ly/3aW0hy6 so you can buy these separately and use it for boules as well as everyday cooking
Hope this helps
Regards
Sushma
Shriram says
Namaskarams
And thank you for such a detailed response.
I just discovered a few days ago that Rock Tawa based in Coimbatore itself makes Dutch ovens . They have a 3 liter and 5 liter...https://rocktawa.com/rock-tawa-dutch-oven-pre-seasoned-best-cast-iron
Will pick one up soon after they are open up. Presently unresponsive due to Covid19 lockdowns I guess. Many thanks again.
By the way today is Day 11 and my Bubbles is still not active. Twice a day discard + feeding is going on at 0600 & 1800. Fingers and toes crossed.
sushma iyer says
Hehe.. I like toes crossed.. What flour are you using Wheat based aa??
Prescy Dias says
I am very happy you have taken so much trouble to explain this in detail and easy steps we can follow. I had some bad experiences years back and there was no one to explain or help out. One question..does the water have to be warm every time it is added. God bless you my dear and all your future endeavours.
sushma iyer says
Hi Prescy..
Thank you for your kind words.. so pleased to know that the information that I have shared is worth a read.. appreciate your feedback. and to answer your query Yes always use warm water.. Yeast loves warm conditions 🙂
Regards
Sushma
Archana Wani says
Hi Sushma,I am not able to understand the concept of changing starter percentage. Can you please help.
sushma iyer says
Hi Archana..
Baker's percentage is the term used to define the percentage of water in the dough aka bread. Flour is always 100 percent and all the other ingredients are calculated based on that. So if for eg: flour is 1000 gms then 70 percent dough means it has 700 gms of water in it.
For a beginner it becomes difficult to handle higher hydration dough like say 75% (750 gms of water as per the above example) or 80% (800 gms of water as per the example) as the dough tends to be sticky and runny.
This recipe is 70% which means the dough has 70 percentage of water in it. If you are not comfortable with the given amount you can use 68% and if you are a seasoned sourdough baker then you can also go for 75% that is what I have mentioned in the notes section.
I have tried this recipe with all the three hydration level and got good results. The more the hydration the better your bread will be.
Hope this helps
Regards
Sushma
Archana Wani says
Hi nice write up. Very comprehensive. I have a query is bulk ferment and bench rest same?
sushma iyer says
Hi Archana.. Thank you.. And to answer your query no they are not the same. You can read sourdough terminologies from here: https://spicesnflavors.com/beginners-sourdough-starter-recipe/3/
Regards
Sushma
Divya Nair says
Thank you Sushma for the detailed explanation. Even the minute details have been covered.
Reshma says
Thanks for amazing write up, very well written. I have a query can we use normal tap water to start with.
sushma iyer says
Hi Reshma..
Glad to know that you found the information useful. Thank you.
Coming to your query no normal tap water is not recommended. What you can do is boil the water well, allow it to cool till warm to touch and then use it..
Regards
Sushma
anisha mehul says
Good job!!
sushma iyer says
Hi Anisha.. Thank you 🙂
anisha mehul says
I am impressed with the level of research you have done and what is even more impressive is you took so much time to blog and share it with everyone.
sushma iyer says
Hi Anisha.. Thank you so much.. You are truly kind-hearted as not everyone can appreciate other's work. Thank you for those kind words.. I am glad that I could be of some help..
Regards
Sushma
Vijay says
Hey Sushma.....I am so happy to learn about your blog on sourdough. I have tried to get a starter going and buried some and eat resurrected some.
Am I glad to have made your acquaintance though.
I think the most important ingredient is flour.
For me APF has not been a 💯 . Where do you get your bread flour? I assume you live here in India.
My sour dough is like a pregnancy. Sometimes it's good sometimes I have miscarriages. HELP NEEDED
sushma iyer says
Hi Vijay..
I do not live in India, I live in New Zealand..
To answer your question I would say the flour really doesn't matter as I have had success with all the three types - Bread, Maida and Whole Wheat. I would say go for whole wheat in that case.. About sourdough failures I can understand I got my first success only in the third attempt.. It is all in the technique I would say.
Regards
Sushma
Rajalakshmy Varadarajan says
Hi I dodnt get my Sour dough tracker.
sushma iyer says
Hi Rajalakshmy..
You have to enter your email address in there and it would be sent to your inbox. Please shoot me a reply from your email address to [email protected] so that I can have look from my end.
Regards
Sushma